Comic character fighting skill rankings

[Morpheus]

Jun 1, 2011 14:52:36 GMT -5 Admin said:

IHMO hasn't had the opportunity to demonstrate against a big name in technique, but his bios/trainings seem to justify a low 5. Feats are limited, but provided in Solo v Moon Knight.

Low-5, then?

[Admin]

Seems more than fair to me.

[Morpheus]

I just got done reading Kirigi's appearances. I kinda want to give him a 5 but the guy only has reputation and a couple of good showings against Elektra (both defeats, though).

[Erik-El]

Jun 1, 2011 14:52:37 GMT -5 Matezoide said:

Jun 1, 2011 14:40:41 GMT -5 Erik-El said:

Due to popular demand, the system has been switched back to the 7 tier system. Now you guys can start posting in it again.

IMO,most people were just used to the 7 system,that's prety much why i wasnt a big fan of it,but i think it is more accurate

Eh it does not really matter too much. I gave Creator the green light to move forward with his 30 tier system so everyone else can have the 18.

[creator]

Jun 1, 2011 15:06:41 GMT -5 Erik-El said:

Eh it does not really matter too much. I gave Creator the green light to move forward with his 30 tier system so everyone else can have the 18.

I had planned to start a new thread using 30 ranks, which is the same for all the grids (Strength, Movement Speed etc).
However if people find this too complicated, how will they cope with trying to populate a lot of grids all comprised of 30 ranks ??

[Erik-El]

I am waiting for you to make your thread Creator.

*Taps foot*

[creator]

Jun 1, 2011 15:18:04 GMT -5 Erik-El said:

I am waiting for you to make your thread Creator.

*Taps foot*

;D

[Strafe Prower]

I'm ready to do all the lists.

[Vance Astro]

Jun 1, 2011 15:02:04 GMT -5 Morpheus said:

I just got done reading Kirigi's appearances. I kinda want to give him a 5 but the guy only has reputation and a couple of good showings against Elektra (both defeats, though).

I agree.In one fight he was fairly close to killing her.

[Morpheus]

Jun 1, 2011 18:35:02 GMT -5 Vance Astro said:

Jun 1, 2011 15:02:04 GMT -5 Morpheus said:

I just got done reading Kirigi's appearances. I kinda want to give him a 5 but the guy only has reputation and a couple of good showings against Elektra (both defeats, though).

I agree.In one fight he was fairly close to killing her.

Yeah, in the first. But his durability played a part, too. She stabbed him with her sais and he was unaffected, then started choking her before she managed to impale him with a katana. Second fight, she hits him with a freaking truck and he's still alive, lol.


It's too bad he doesn't have more feats/appearances. Despite losing to her twice, he did have premise. The Chaste stomped him utterly, though.

[Vance Astro]

Jun 1, 2011 18:38:43 GMT -5 Morpheus said:

Jun 1, 2011 18:35:02 GMT -5 Vance Astro said:

I agree.In one fight he was fairly close to killing her.

Yeah, in the first. But his durability played a part, too. She stabbed him with her sais and he was unaffected, then started choking her before she managed to impale him with a katana. Second fight, she hits him with a freaking truck and he's still alive, lol.


It's too bad he doesn't have more feats/appearances. Despite losing to her twice, he did have premise. The Chaste stomped him utterly, though.

I hope Mark Waid will touch back on the Hand.It would be nice to know how skilled their highest ranking members actually are.There are alot of high ranking hand member that we've really haven't seen much from.Of course Kirigi,Bakuto,and Izanami are dead but apparently The Hand has no problem bring people back from the dead.

[Pirateking69]

Blue Beetle(Ted Kord) been ranked? didn't see him

[ronniebolt]

Elektra should be moved to a 5. She's mediorce and stalemates by black widow.

[Admin]

Oh, snap.

[Morpheus]

Jun 1, 2011 21:07:06 GMT -5 Vance Astro said:

Jun 1, 2011 18:38:43 GMT -5 Morpheus said:

Yeah, in the first. But his durability played a part, too. She stabbed him with her sais and he was unaffected, then started choking her before she managed to impale him with a katana. Second fight, she hits him with a freaking truck and he's still alive, lol.


It's too bad he doesn't have more feats/appearances. Despite losing to her twice, he did have premise. The Chaste stomped him utterly, though.

I hope Mark Waid will touch back on the Hand.It would be nice to know how skilled their highest ranking members actually are.There are alot of high ranking hand member that we've really haven't seen much from.Of course Kirigi,Bakuto,and Izanami are dead but apparently The Hand has no problem bring people back from the dead.

Damn, sorry for the delay, Vance.


I read the issues Izanami appeared in, and while she showed premise, she appeared to rely more on her bulk and her strength/durability rather than her skill. I'd be very interested to see more of Kirigi, who is criminally underused IMO, and Bakuto is one of the recent additions to the Hand mythos that caught my eye, too. And yeah, resurrection should be nothing for the Hand. They already resurrected Kirigi twice, anyway.


I'd want DD to start using his armor again, though. I haven't gotten to the issues where he stops using it, but it's comfortable and very useful so I don't see why he'd feasibly stop wearing it.

[Painkiller]

Has Jason Todd been ranked yet? (I'd put him at a Mid 5, personally)

[devias]

Jun 6, 2011 5:46:04 GMT -5 Painkiller said:

Has Jason Todd been ranked yet? (I'd put him at a Mid 5, personally)

I'd place him at High 5. Anywhere below Nightwing is fine.

[Accord_Royal1738]

Good list overall, but I think Crossbones should be low tier 7. Mandarin is pretty underrated as well IMO....... Otherwise, no complaints.

[Dane]

Crossbones isn't even close to tier 7.

[Admin]

I think Crossbones is fine with his current placement (he's med 6, right?)